Court of Appeals of Texas February 7, 1941, No. 2096. (Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co. v. Graves)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-02-1941

FUNDERBURK, Justice.

Carroll Graves, an employee of West Texas Cotton Oil Company, suffered an accidental injury on January 16, 1938, while in the course of his employment. • His claim for compensation insurance was settled by a compromise agreement approved by the Industrial Accident Board. In accordance with the settlement agreement said employee was paid the sum of $10 by Hartford Accident & Indemnity Company, the insurance carrier for said employer. Afterwards said Carroll Graves, who will hereinafter be referred to as the employee,

*860

brought this suit against said Hartford Accident & Indemnity Company, hereinafter referred to as the insurer, to set aside said compromise settlement on the ground that he was induced by fraud to enter into the agreement and accept the $10 in payment of his claim.

In a jury trial the case was submitted upon special issues, all of which, unless it was Special Issue No. 5, were found in favor of the employee. The insurer duly filed a motion for judgment entitled “Motion for Judgment Non Obstante Veredic-to.” In said motion it was alleged that the “court erred in submitting said special issues (referring to all of the issues as thereinbefore set out) or any of them, to the jury and that said findings are wrong, (with the exception of the answer to Special Issue No. 5) and all others

except No. 5

should be held for naught”, etc. (Italics ours.) The motion further alleges “that judgment should be entered for the defendant notwithstanding the answers to all the issues submitted by the court to the jury

with the exception

of Special Issue No. 5, and the defendant calls to the court’s attention the fact that by answering Special Issue No. 5, as it did to the effect that Dr. Clark, the defendant’s physician at the time he gave certain advice to the plaintiff, did not know that the plaintiff was contemplating a compromise settlement with the defendant, and it is submitted, therefore, that the statement made by Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.