Utah Supreme Court June 25, 1941, No. 6299. (Walker Bank & Trust Co. v. State Tax Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-06-1941

LARSON, Justice.

On October 11, 1935, Angelena A. Walker, the trustor, created an irrevocable trust, by which agreement certain stocks were transferred to the Walker Bank & Trust Company, as trustee. The income from the trust property was to be paid to the trustor during her lifetime, and upon her death the trust estate was to be divided into three shares, the income from each share to be paid to a named beneficiary during his or her lifetime, and upon the death of each such beneficiary, that share of the corpus is to be paid to certain other designated beneficiaries, the grandchildren of the trustor. The trustee was given control and management of the corpus with the exception of the voting rights in connection with the stocks, which were given to the daughter of the trustor exclusively. In addition to being directed to pay the net income to the trustor for her life the trustee “may also pay to the Trustor such amounts in addition from the corpus, as, in the sole judgment of the Trustee may be reasonably required, especially in an emergency, for her proper support, maintenance, and general welfare.”

*309

..June 9,1939, the trustor died and the executor, the trustee, refused to include the. trust property in. the inheritance tax report and appraisement, claiming the property is not subject to the inheritance tax laws of the State of Utah. The District Court, on petition of the State Tax Commission, held the trust property to be subject to the Utah tax in accordance with Chapter 12, Title 80, R. S. U. 1933. The bank appealed from the district court’s order that it file a supplemental inventory of the property so transferred and have the property appraised for tax purposes. The errors assigned are (1) that the trial court erred in overruling appellant’s demurrer to the commission’s petition; and (2) that the trial court erred in rendering its judgment to the effect that the transfer is taxable under the provisions of Chapter 12, Title 80, R. S. U.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.