Utah Supreme Court February 19, 1941, No. 6258. (Genola Town v. Santaquin City)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-02-1941

lead-opinion

This is an appeal from a judgment of the District Court of Utah County adjudging the individual defendants guilty of contempt for violating a judgment and decree of the court, entered September 13, 1937, in an action entitled Genola Town v. Santaquin City et al., which judgment and decree were by this court affirmed July 6, 1938, 96 Utah 88, 80 P.2d 930, 935. That was an action to compel Santaquin City to specifically perform a contract to deliver a certain amount of water from its water system to that of Genola Town. Santaquin City defended in that action upon the ground, inter alia, that the contract was null and void as a violation of the provisions of Article 11, Section 6, of the Constitution of Utah. The lower court decreed specific performance and this court affirmed the decree. During the month of August, 1939, the individual defendants as the Mayor and City Council of Santaquin City knowingly and deliberately failed and refused to deliver to plaintiff the quantity of water provided in the decree. For their failure to do so they were adjudged in contempt of court and appeal. While a number of errors are assigned, they present but a single question. At the outset of their brief, defendants (appellants) state the matter in this language: "We approach the problem of this case fully aware of the fact that this Court has affirmed a judgment decreeing specific performance of the original contract between Santaquin and Genola. At the outset we disclaim any attempt by this appeal to litigate that matter a second time. Our purpose here is to procure from this Court an adjudication of the meaning of the original decree in the light of the constitutional provision of this state touching the matter of the culinary water supply of a municipality." *Page 64 For a statement of the issues, facts, and circumstances involved in the original trial, we refer the reader to the opinion of this court, cited supra.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.