Supreme Court of Vermont October 7, 1941 (Tinney v. Crosby)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-10-1941
Moulton, C. J.
Tbe plaintiff was struck and severely injured by a stone thrown as tbe result of a blasting operation, in which be was employed. He brought this action in tort against tbe defendant, who was in charge, alleging negligence in tbe amount of explosive used, in tbe manner of placing it, and in failing to supply him with a safe place in which to do bis work. Tbe verdict was for tbe plaintiff, and tbe cause is here on tbe defendant’s exceptions. These exceptions are to tbe admission of certain opinion evidence, and to tbe denial of a motion for a verdict.
Tbe exceptions to tbe evidence present only one question. Tbe plaintiff called several witnesses who testified to their experience in blasting and in tbe use of dynamite and other explosives. Each was asked substantially tbe same questions and was permitted to give substantially tbe same answers, subject to clearly expressed exceptions by tbe defendant. One instance will suffice to illustrate the point involved.
*99
The witness Adelord Merrow was asked whether, based upon the evidence in the ease, he had an opinion as to the cause of the injury to the plaintiff, and answered that he had. The next question was: ‘ ‘ State what in your opinion was the cause of the injury to this plaintiff?”, to which he replied “Well I should call it negligent use of high explosive. ’ ’ A motion to strike out this testimony was made and denied, subject to defendant’s exception.
No. 47 of the Acts of 1939, upon which the plaintiff relies to support the rulings to which we have just referred, reads as follows : ‘ ‘ Section 1.
Experts, testimony.
An expert witness may be asked to state his opinions, whether these opinions are based upon the witness’ personal observation, or on evidence introduced at the trial and seen or heard by the witness, or on his technical knowledge of the subject, without first specifying hypothetically in the question the data on which these opinions are based. Section 2.
Same.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit