Washington Supreme Court September 22, 1941, No. 28328. (City Sanitary Service Co. v. Rausch)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-09-1941
Main, J.
The plaintiff brought this action seeking injunctive relief. The trial to the court without a jury resulted in a decree permanently enjoining the defendants from doing the thing of which the plaintiff complained. From this decree the defendants appeal.
The respondent is a corporation organized under the laws of this state. The appellants are husband and wife, and reside near the city of Wenatchee. August 19, 1940, the city, by its board of commissioners, passed an ordinance, designated as ordinance No. 967. August 26, 1940, the city acting through its commissioners, entered into a contract with the respondent wherein the city granted to the respondent the exclusive right to collect garbage within the city for a period from August 26, 1940, to April 1, 1950. The ordinance and contract were introduced for first reading at the regular meeting of the commissioners August 12,1940, and on the nineteenth day of August of that year the ordinance came up for final reading and was passed. It thus appears that the ordinance was passed less than thirty days after its introduction.
The appellants’ first contention is that the ordinance, in effect, granted to the respondent a franchise, and they call our attention to Rem. Rev. Stat., § 9038
*448
[P. C. § 744], which provides that no ordinance granting a franchise or any valuable privilege in a city shall be passed “on the day of its introduction nor for thirty days thereafter.” As above appears, the ordinance in question was passed less than thirty days after its introduction.
In the case of
Wallis v. Fidelity & Deposit Co.,
155 Wash. 618, 285 Pac. 656, it was distinctly held that a garbage ordinance did not grant a franchise. In that case, it was pointed out that the case of
Cornelius v. Seattle,
123 Wash. 550, 213 Pac. 17, was to the same effect. The appellants recognize the force of these decisions and attempt to distinguish the
Cornelius
case and ask us to overrule the
Wallis
case.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit