Wisconsin Supreme Court December 3, 1941 (Fay v. City of Green Bay)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-12-1941
The following opinion was filed January 13, 1942:
Fritz, J.
Defendant appeals from a judgment for the recovery by plaintiff of damages for injuries sustained in a fall caused by her foot becoming caught under a protruding-spike in a crosswalk. The jury found that the crosswalk was in an unsafe condition for public use; that such condition was a cause of the plaintiff’s fall and injury, and had existed for such length of time prior to plaintiff’s fall that defendant in the exercise of ordinary care ought to have discovered the condition in time to have repaired it; that negligence on plaintiff’s part contributed in causing her injury and constituted
*38
twenty per cent of the total causal negligence; and that her damages amounted to $4,500.
Defendant contends that the spike under which plaintiff claims her foot became caught did not constitute an actionable defect; that it was not in the crosswalk in that condition a sufficient length of time to put the city on notice; and that the spike introduced in evidence was not sufficiently identified. In order to pass upon these contentions it suffices to note that there was testimony to the following effect. The accident happened at about 8 :45 p. m. on August 17, 1S140> while plaintiff was walking in a normal manner on a crosswalk consisting of wooden planks laid by the city many years ago. The toe of the right shoe became caught under a bent, hooklike spike which protruded two1 to two and one-half inches above a wooden plank, and as she tried to twist the shoe loose, but could not, she suddenly fell down on her right shoulder. A witness, Mrs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit