Wisconsin Supreme Court February 4, 1941 (Boynton Cab Co. v. Giese)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-1941

Feitz, J.

The defendant, Henry Giese, was employed for about four years (except for a brief interval in February, 1938) as a taxicab driver by the appellant, Boynton Cab Company, until it discharged him on November 18, 1938. Upon his filing a claim for unemployment benefits under ch. 108, Stats., the commission gave due notice thereof to appellant in compliance with sec. 108.09 (1), Stats., and under the procedure authorized by that subsection appellant filed with the commission a written rejection of the claim on the ground that “Giese was discharged . . .

because of dishonesty.” A

deputy designated by the commission made an

ex parte

investigation and an “initial determination” that the

*240

discharge was not for such misconduct as to render Giese ineligible under sec. 108.04 (4) (a), Stats., for unemployment benefits. Thereupon appellant requested a hearing and the commission designated an appeal tribunal to hear and decide the disputed claim. The tribunal held a hearing, as a trial

de novo,

at which it received sworn testimony which was taken down by an official stenographic reporter, together with all other proceedings at the hearing, and his transcript thereof constitutes the record upon which the tribunal made findings of fact and a decision which sustained the initial determination and allowed benefits accordingly. Upon appellant’s petition for a review of this decision, the commission reviewed the record of the hearing before the tribunal, and then adopted and affirmed the latter’s decision. Appellant brought this actio'n for a judicial review of the commission’s decision, including the allowance of unemployment benefits to Giese, and upon the entry of judgment affirming that decision appellant appealed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.