United States Board of Tax Appeals October 8, 1941, Docket No. 102985. (Miller v. Commissioner)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-10-1941
lead-opinion
*297OPINION.
Black :
In support of his contention that the Board should allow the full amount of his claimed loss of $20,000, the petitioner- cites City Builders Finance Co., 21 B. T. A. 800, and Peabody Coal Co. v. United States, 8 Fed. Supp. 845. We have examined these cases and we do not think they are in point.
In the City Builders Finance Co. case, the taxpayer was the owner of 32y2 shares of stock in another corporation and had a cost basis therefor which was not in dispute. The 32y2 shares which it owned was a one-eighth interest in the other corporation. In the taxable year a 100 percent stock dividend was declared and paid in order to give an interest to an outside party which was to render certain aid to the corporation. The taxpayer had to turn in its part of this stock dividend for issuance to this outside party. When all this was finished the taxpayer owned only a one-sixteenth interest in the corporation, whereas prior to the transaction in question the taxpayer owned a one-eighth interest in the corporation. Under these circumstances we allowed the taxpayer to deduct the full cost allocated to the shares which it turned in for issuance to the outside party. In that case none of the stock was turned in to the issuing corporation for cancellation and retirement by it, and the book value of the taxpayer’s remaining stock in the corporation was not increased.
In the instant case, the 200 shares of stock in the shoe company were not reissued to some outside party, as was the case in City Builders Finance Co., supra, but were canceled by the shoe company. To the same effect as was our decision in City Builders Finance Co., supra, was the decision of the Court of Claims in Peabody Coal Co. v. United States, supra.
*298In the Peabody Coad Co. case the taxpayer transferred a part of the stock which it owned in a subsidiary corporation to some investment bankers in consideration of their lending their services in financing the subsidiary.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit