Texas Supreme Court April 9, 1941, No. 7723 (Friedman v. American Surety Co. of New York)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-1941

lead-opinion

Mr. Justice Critz

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This is a certified question from the Court of Civil Appeals for the Second District at Fort Worth. The certificate is accompanied by a tentative opinion, as required by our rules. The certificate is as follows:

*152“TO THE SUPREME COURT OF TEXAS:

“This is an appeal by Harry B. Friedman from an adverse judgment entered against him in a cause in which he sued American Surety Company of New York, as surety on a bond executed by F. M. Kuhlman, as principal, and that company, as surety. Allegations were made that Kuhlman was insolvent and the company alone was sued.

“Friedman’s petition shows that he was the original contractor for the construction of a building for Fort Worth Independent School District; that he sublet to Kuhlman the lath and plaster work; that he held a contract with Kuhlman for the work covered by the subcontract, by which Kuhlman was to perform the work set out therein and would pay all claims arising thereunder for which he, Friedman, could be held liable, and that the American Surety Company of New York guaranteed Kuhlman’s faithful performance of the contract; that after he (Friedman) had paid Kuhlman the contract price provided for in the contract, the Unemployment Compensation Commission of Texas demanded of him, Friedman, the payment of a tax owing to the Texas Unemployment Compensation Fund, amounting to $293.98, on the labor performed by Kuhlman’s employees, since Kuhlman was not an employer under the law. The payment was made by Friedman and he asserted his right to collect it back from Kuhlman under the law as it was alleged to have existed at all times prior to the institution of the suit on October 31st, 1938.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.