Texas Supreme Court July 9, 1941, No. 7611 (Chalmers v. Gumm)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-07-1941
Mr. Judge Hickman
delivered the opinion of the Commission of Appeals, Section A.
Defendant in error, Charles A. Gumm, alleging himself to be “a nephew and heir at law of Fred Erichson” brought this action in the County Court of Harris County to set aside the probate of the will of Fred Erichson, deceased. The alleged grounds for. setting aside the will and the probate thereof, were: First, lack of testamentary capacity, and, second, undue influence exercised upon the testator by certain persons named as beneficiaries in the will. A trial of the case in the county court resulted in a judgment setting aside the order probating the will. On appeal the case was submitted in the district court upon one special issue. By its answer to that issue the jury found that the testator was lacking in testamentary capacity on the date the will was executed. Thereafter, the proponents filed a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict. That motion was granted and judgment was rendered that the plaintiff, Gumm, and certain other alleged relatives who intervened in the cause, take nothing, and that their application to set aside the probate of the will be dismissed. That judgment was reversed by the Court of Civil Appeals and the cause remanded generally to the trial court for another trial. 127 S. W. (2d) 942.
The motion for judgment non obstanto veredicto was based upon two grounds: First, that there was no evidence of testamentary incapacity, and second, that there was no evidence that Gumm had the requisite interest in the estate to authorize him to prosecute the suit.
We agree with the holding of the Court of Civil Appeals that there was evidence of testamentary incapacity and perceive no reason for writing further upon that question. It would appear that the trial court sustained only the second ground of the motion, as otherwise its- judgment would not have been one dismissing the contest.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit