Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York February 18, 1941 (Hunter v. Fitz-Roy Development Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-02-1941

Carswell, J.

The defendant owns an apartment house in Kew Gardens with stores on the ground floor. The property on its uortherly and easterly sides abuts public highways, that is, Lefferts avenue and Austin street. A station of the Long Island railroad immediately adjoins the property on the southerly and westerly sides. Adjacent to the Long Island railroad station *271there is a sidewalk at the rear of and wholly upon defendant’s property. The public traverses this sidewalk from Lefferts avenue to the railroad station and also to the several stores in defendant’s building, entered from this sidewalk. At the corner of Austin street and the sidewalk leading to the railroad station there was, on defendant’s property, a drug store, and nearby, abutting this sidewalk, on defendant’s property, was a vacant store.

On January 26, 1939, plaintiff walked along Lefferts avenue until he reached the sidewalk at the rear of defendant’s property. He was on his way to the drug store located in defendant’s building, after which he purposed taking a train to New York. He turned off Lefferts avenue and onto the sidewalk, going in the direction of the drug store. While so proceeding he fell on a dangerous accumulation of snow and ice on the sidewalk in front of the vacant store. He suffered injuries, for which he has had a judgment.

The defendant asserts that it is not liable because it is the owner of the servient estate in respect of this sidewalk; that the duty to maintain the sidewalk in a safe condition rests upon the owners of the dominant estates under an instrument executed and recorded by defendant’s predecessor in May, 3925. That instrument accorded a permanent right of way to the owners of premises adjoining defendant’s property (Long Island railroad and others); a right of way to the general public over this sidewalk, and a means of access for pedestrians to premises adjoining the aforesaid right of way.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.