Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York October 31, 1941 (Rotnofsky v. Capitol Distributors Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-10-1941

lead-opinion

Callahan, J.

Plaintiff, a chauffeur formerly employed by defendant corporation, sues for breach of contract of employment. *522He claims the right to recover damages because of his discharge on May. 3, 1940, contending that he had a binding contract which continued his employment to December 13, 1941.

Plaintiff concedes that no contract was entered into directly between himself and the defendant, but asserts that his rights arise under an agreement made between a labor union, of which he is a member, and the defendant. This agreement is in writing and contains terms usually found in a collective bargaining agreement. It states that the parties making the contract are the “ employer ” (the defendant) and the “ union ” (The Drivers & Chauffeurs Local Union No. 816). It recites the nature of the employer’s business, and states that, for the purpose of insuring a satisfactory agreement with those employees who are engaged in the distribution of its products, it will employ only chauffeurs and helpers who are members of the contracting union. All employees so hired by defendant are required to make application for membership in the union, and, if rejected for membership, the employer agrees to discharge such employees immediately. The contract then proceeds to set forth numerous terms with relation to wages, hours and conditions of employment. It then recites as follows:

“ 6. Discharge — The employer will not discharge any of its employees within the classes provided for herein for union activities.

“ In discharging, for economic reasons, the employer will abide by and follow seniority.

“ The employer agrees not to discharge any regular employee provided for herein, except for cause, upon one week’s notice, except in the case of dishonesty where no notice shall be required. The employees, desiring to terminate their employment with the employer, shall give one week’s notice to the employer of their intention so to do.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.