Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York October 31, 1941 (Becker v. Manufacturers Trust Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-10-1941

Callahan, J.

Plaintiff’s son subleased a store at Rockaway Beach, New York city, from one Sweet, who was the tenant of the whole building in which said store was located. The building was a two-story structure, on the ground floor of which there were four stores facing the boardwalk, and on the second floor numerous sleeping rooms. The premises accordingly came within the definition of a multiple dwelling. (Multiple Dwelling Law, § 4.)

Sweet had leased the premises from the Mortgage Commission Realty Corporation in February, 1938, for a period to end October 31, 1939. Prior to the accident in question, which occurred on July 10, 1938, title to the fee had been conveyed to the appellant, subject to existing tenancies.

After entering into possession plaintiff’s son erected a canvas partition in the store, separating the front part from the rear. The front portion was used for the customary concession purposes, and the rear was used as living quarters.

On July 10, 1938, while plaintiff was going to a toilet in the rear of the premises, a portion of the ceiling fell and struck her on the head, causing her to suffer physical injuries.

Plaintiff brought this action for damages against the owner, availing herself of the provisions of section 78 of the Multiple Dwelling Law, which provide that every portion of such premises shall be kept in good repair, and that the owner shall be responsible for failure to comply with the provisions of the section. Recognizing, however, that notice of a dangerous condition was an essential element of liability on the part of defendant owner, plaintiff proceeded upon the trial solely on the theory of actual notice. No claim of constructive notice was asserted.

The trial court, in its charge to the jury, made no reference to the rules concerning constructive notice, but referred to the only proof of actual notice contained in the evidence, to wit, actual notice alleged to have been given by plaintiff’s son to his landlord, Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.