Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 12, 1941 (Futterer v. Saratoga Ass'n for Improvement of the Breed of Horses)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-11-1941

Foster, J.

Plaintiff was a patron at the defendant’s race track at Saratoga, N. Y., on August 4,1939, and had paid admission for a seat in the grandstand. Between the second and third races he went to the paddock. While returning to his seat, and proceeding along the main aisle of the grandstand, he claims to have been jostled and pushed with great force and violence by other patrons of the defendant through an opening into one of the private boxes which was next to the main aisle. For the injuries which he sustained as a result of this accident he has recovered a judgment of $2,000 against the defendant.

It appears that the grandstand faced generally east, and had a main aisle, about four feet wide, which ran along and parallel to the front of the grandstand. To the east of and. next to the main aisle there was a row of private boxes, consisting of wooden *676inclosures, with openings about three feet wide directly onto the main aisle. The floor of these boxes was thirteen inches lower than the level of the aisle. It is into one of these boxes that plaintiff claims to have been pushed.

On the day of the accident there were 6,350 people on the grounds, including those in the grandstand, club house, fieldstand, betting ring and on the lawn. There is no exact account of the number of patrons in the grandstand, which had a capacity of 3,300, but there is no evidence that it was overcrowded. For the protection and convenience of the patrons in the grandstand the defendant provided twenty-five uniformed ushers, six patrolmen and thirteen plainclothes men.

It is" plaintiff’s contention that when he was returning from the paddock, and walking along the main aisle to reach his seat, a crowd of from twelve to twenty men rushed along this aisle, apparently to place last minute bets. One or more of them struck him and he was thrown through the opening of one of the boxes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.