New York Surrogate's Court June 13, 1941 (In re the Estate of Zweig)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-06-1941

Foley, S.

The principal issue in this discovery proceeding involves a claim by one of the respondents, Leon Folman, to a gift causa mortis by the decedent in the sum of $1,000. The administrator sought the recovery of other items of personal property which he asserted in his petition were assets of the estate. Both respondents conceded the right of the administrator to the possession of these remaining items and they were turned over to him in open court.

As to the sum of $1,000, the surrogate holds that a valid gift causa mortis was made to the extent of $340. It is disallowed as to the balance of $660.

There are exceptional circumstances in the testimony which, it is claimed by the administrator, throw doubt upon the transactions. The donee of the gift was a nephew. The moneys and property owned by the decedent at the time of the transaction were relatively small in amount and value. The value of the alleged gift constituted a substantial part of the decedent’s holdings. The decedent’s immediate family consisted of an adult son and daughter. It is asserted by the administrator that under these circumstances she would not have made a comparatively large gift to a more distant relation, a nephew. On the other hand, the proof of the gift, to the extent allowed, is sufficiently clear' and convincing. The transfers of moneys are evidenced by instruments concededly executed by the decedent a few days before her death. It is also clear that she was under the apprehension of death at the time. The necessary elements of a gift causa mortis have been shown. (Ridden v. Thrall, 125 N. Y. 572.)

*771The partial disallowance of the claim is based here upon a different theory of the law of gifts. The moneys were paid over upon the draft and check to one of the respondents, Hyman Folman, the brother of the donee. He testified in substance that the decedent instructed him to give the sum of $1,000 out of these moneys to his brother. He was thereby constituted her agent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.