New York Court of Claims September 12, 1941, Claim No. 25154 (MacFarland v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-09-1941

Barrett, P. J.

This is a claim for damages caused by the overflow of the waters of Oneida lake, the State’s liability having been fixed in the case of Haskell v. State of New York (258 App. Div. 930; affd., 283 N. Y. 612). In the claim of Slocum v. State of New York (177 Misc. 114), wherein the property was owned by tenants in common, but the claim was filed by but one tenant, the motion by claimant to add the name of the other tenant as a party claimant was denied. Here the property was owned,by claimant and his wife as tenants by the entirety. The claim was filed by the husband and a motion made to amend the claim by adding thereto the name of the wife as a party claimant. The question arises as to whether the decision in Slocum v. State of New York (supra) is conclusive.

In Grosser v. City of Rochester (148 N. Y. 235) it was held that a wife having an interest as a tenant by the entirety could sue alone to restrain an injury to her interest. In Matter of Goodrich v. *118Village of Otego (216 N. Y. 112) it was held that a tenant by the entirety is a tenant in common with a right of survivorship; that one tenant by the entirety may recover damages for injuries to his interest even though the other tenant by the entirety is barred from recovering by reason of the failure to duly file a claim. In D’Angelo v. New York Central R. R. Co. (209 App. Div. 775) it was held that one cotenant by entirety could recover for his damages to his interests in the property involved. In Mastrofrancisco v. Mohawk Gas Co. (201 App. Div. 586) it was held that during the lifetime of the husband and wife, their tenancy is the same as that of a tenancy in common, that the husband may sue without joining his cotenant but that he may recover only the damages to his interests. In Gray v. State of New York (116 Misc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.