New York Surrogate's Court October 10, 1941 (In re the Estate of Hertzig)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-10-1941
Foley, S.
In this application for a construction of the will a preliminary question is raised as to the admissibility of extrinsic evidence in order to determine the identity of a legatee. In her will the testatrix made the following charitable bequest:
“ I give, devise and bequeath to the following charitable institutions, the sums set opposite their names, as follows:
“ 1. Denver National Jewish Hospital, Denver, Colorado, the sum of Five Hundred ($500.00) Dollars.”
i There is no corporation having the exact corporate title set forth in the will. Two charitable corporations claim this legacy: (1) National Jewish Hospital at Denver and (2) The Jewish Consumptives’ Relief Society, sometimes known as Denver Sanitarium.
*599The first corporation contends that there is really no ambiguity in the will since its corporate title is almost exactly similar to the description of the legatee in the will. This corporation, therefore, argues that there is no necessity for the introduction of extrinsic evidence and that it is entitled to payment of the legacy.
The second corporation claiming the legacy contends that the misdescription of the legatee in itself creates an ambiguity. It is alleged on behalf of this corporation that the testatrix in her lifetime was active in its affairs. It is further alleged by the attorney who drew the will that the original instructions given to him by the testatrix and the original draft of the will clearly indicate that the Jewish Consumptives’ Relief Society, sometimes known as Denver Sanitarium, was the corporation intended by the testatrix as the legatee.
Under the early rule the courts were hesitant to admit extrinsic evidence in the construction of wills, preferring to rely upon the written words wherever possible. (St. Luke’s Home v. Association for Indigent Females, 52 N. Y. 191; Union Trust Co. v. St. Luke’s Hospital, 74 App. Div. 330; affd., 175 N. Y. 505.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit