City of New York Municipal Court December 5, 1941 (Goor v. Navilio)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-12-1941
O'Rourke, J.
Plaintiff seeks to recover damages for injury to a roll of film conceded to have been damaged while in the possession of the defendant, who was intrusted with it for the purposes of processing.
The issues have been submitted to this court upon an agreed statement of facts, which are as follows:
Plaintiff purchased one hundred feet of black and white film from the defendant and took the same with him to Florida, where he went for a vacation with his wife and two children. While there, he used the film, taking pictures of his family. Upon returning to New York, he delivered the film to the defendant for develop*971ing and printing and it is conceded that the same was ruined in the course of processing. By reason thereof, plaintiff instituted this action for breach of the contract of bailment and seeks to recover $141, representing the alleged cost of fares to Florida and Washington, D. C., and hotel expense in order to replace the film with the Florida background.
The defense herein of limited liability is based upon the printed clause set forth upon the outer wrapping of the film which reads: “ The film in this carton has been made with great care and will be processed in our laboratory without additional charge. If we find this film to have been defective in manufacture or to have been damaged in our laboratory we will replace it, but we assume no other responsibility, either expressed or implied.”
The above clause appears quite legibly, and is unambiguous in its language.
The general rule is that, where property is wrongfully damaged through the defendant’s negligent acts, the measure of recovery is a just indemnity to the owner for the loss which is the natural, reasonable and proximate result of the act complained of. To arrive at this loss, where the property has a special value to the owner as distinguished from what it can be sold for, an allowance on the former basis must be made. (Starkey v. Kelly, 50 N. Y. 676.)
In Lake v. Dye (232 N. Y.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit