Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court April 17, 1941 (Neu v. McCarthy)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-04-1941
Qua, J.
The plaintiff was injured on September 9, 1938, at about 2:30 p.m. by a collision between “a United States Army truck” operated by him and an automobile operated by the defendant. The accident occurred in Dedham at the intersection of the “Circumferential Highway,” known as “Route 128,” which runs north and south, and a county way known as “Route 109,” which runs east and west. The plaintiff was travelling north on “Route 128,” and the defendant was travelling west on “Route 109.” Traffic lights had been installed at the intersection by the proper authorities. In answer to special questions the jury found that the accident was caused by the negligence of both parties, and that the plaintiff drove his truck into the intersection “in disobedience of the rule [of the department of public works] directing traffic on State highways to stop outside of the intersection while the red light is displayed.” Both parties have filed exceptions.
There was evidence of the conduct of the parties that required the submission to the jury of the issues of due care or negligence of both plaintiff and defendant. In this respect the case is not materially different from many other cases of street crossing collisions, and nothing would be gained by a recital of the evidence. The principal question is whether the plaintiff, a private in the United States Army, was under a legal obligation to obey the traffic lights. On the record before us this is important for its bearing upon the issue of contributory negligence which the jury determined adversely to the plaintiff. See Herman v. Sladofsky, 301 Mass. 534, 538; VanDresser v. Firlings, 305 Mass. 51, 55, 56.
The truck driven by the plaintiff was seventh or eighth in a line or convoy of army trucks commanded by a Captain Boettcher, who rode in a beach wagon at the head of the line. Earlier in the day the convoy had taken a load of baggage from Fort Devens in Ayer to Fort Adams in *19Newport, Rhode Island.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit