United States District Court October 20, 1941, No. 2754 (MacNeil Bros. v. Tanzella)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-10-1941

JONES, P. J.

(Pettingell, J., and Sullivan, J.)—This is an action of contract, in which .the plaintiff seeks to recover damages against the defendants for breach of a written contract ma<Ie August 15, 1938, to segregate, load and deliver riprap and" crushed stone to the Cape Cod Canal for use by the United States Government in the repair of said Canal.

The contract, in behalf of the plaintiff, was signed “Mac-Neil Bros. Company, by A. M. MacNeil,” and in behalf" of *145the defendants by Edmund Scotti and Nicholas Tansella & Sons, by Philip Tansella.”

The Court found for the plaintiff against the defendants Scotti and Philip Tanzella, in the sum of one thousand dollars with casts, and in favor of the defendant Nicholas Tansella, father of said Philip Tamjella.

The plaintiff, claiming to be aggrieved by the rulings and refusals to rule as requested in respect to the defendant Nicholas Tansella, the court reported the same to this Division for determination, upon the express stipulation by both of the parties, that in the event the Court erred judgment is to be entered for the plaintiff in the amount of the damages found by the Court, to wit:—one thousand dollars, plus interest, otherwise judgment to be entered for the defendants.

The principle has been laid down by numerous decisions , that a trial judge sitting without a jury must correctly instruct himself as to the governing rules of law, and must pass upon' pertinent requests for rulings of law presented to him for this purpose in such a way as to make it plain that he has not fallen into error. Pevey v. Colonial Beacon Oil Co. 294 Mass. 86, 93. Home Savings Bank v. Samuel Savransky et al, 307 Mass. 601.

Plaintiff’s requests 10, 11, 16 and 17 were properly denied.

It is difficult, however, to reconcile the refusal of the trial judge to grant plaintiff’s requests numbered 7, 9 and 15 with his giving plaintiff’s requests for rulings above referred to, and his findings of facts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.