Ohio Court of Appeals March 17, 1941, No 17937 (Gates-McDonald Co. v. McQuilkin)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-03-1941
OPINION
By MORGAN, J.
The plaintiff m this case is seeking an injunction against the defendant for the purpose of enforcing a negative ¡covenant in a contract of employment.
The plaintiff is an Ohio corporation engaged in furnishing a service throughout the state of Ohio chiefly in the Workmen's Compensation and Social Security field.
Prior to April, 1937, the defendant for three and one-half years had been in the employ of the Industrial Commis*482sion of Ohio. On April 29, 1937, plaintiff and defendant entered into a contract of employment which was later superseded by a contract dated February 7, 1938. By the terms of this latter contract the defendant agreed to continue in the employment of plaintiff, and the plaintiff agreed to employ the defendant beginning February 7, 1938, for a period of three (3) months thereafter, "and so much longer thereafter as said party of the first part (the plaintiff) may care to do so.”
The defendant agreed that if at any time his services with the plaintiff should cease and terminate, the defendant would not, within three years thereafter, “make his services available directly or indirectly to Ohio employers in the matter of rendering them any service in connection with their workmen’s compensation insurance matters, without first securing the written consent of the party of the first part.”
The defendant had charge of the plaintiff’s Cleveland office, and continued therein until September 1, 1938, when, without previous intimation of plaintiff’s intention, he was discharged.
About six weeks after his discharge, the defendant engaged on his own account in Cuyahoga County in the business of selling a service to employer’s in workmen’s compensation matters, and in this work he solicited a few of plaintiff’s clients and was employed by at least two of them.
The question to be determined in this caoe is the validity or invalidity of the negative covenant in the contract between the parties.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit