Supreme Court of Virginia April 21, 1941, Record No. 2340 (Pretlow v. Pretlow)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-04-1941
Holt, J.,
delivered the opinion of the court.
Louise Curdts Story Pretlow, plaintiff in the court below and appellant here, married Robert Ashton Pret*528low on March 10, 1937. Her maiden name was Curdts. In 1917 she married a Mr. Story and with him moved to the town of Franklin. He died in 1927, leaving two children, Dorothy, then ten years old, and Elliott, six, fruits of that marriage. After Mr. Story’s death she continued to make that town her home. Mr. Pretlow was a widower who also lived in Franklin. He had three children, all of whom are now living- and one of whom lives with him.
As might have been expected, Mr. Pretlow and Mrs. Story were casual friends, but his interest in her became more than casual in the autumn of 1936. About the first of February, 1937, he proposed marriage and was then accepted.. On March 6, 1937, an ante-nuptial settlement was entered into, and they were married four days thereafter. Mr. Pretlow was then 67 years old and she was 44. She moved into the Pretlow home and lived there about six months. In June, 1938, she filed her bill charging cruelty and desertion and asked that she be given divorce from bed and board. To that bill was filed an answer and cross-bill, which cross-bill was, in turn, answered. The marriage settlement, cross-bill and answer thereto will be found in a footnote.* To the cross-bill a demurrer was also interposed.
*529The major objections set out in the demurrer to the cross-bill are that it is multifarious and that equity jurisdiction is not conferred by statute and therefore does not exist.
The court was of opinion that fraud which goes to the fundamentals of marriage relations gives jurisdiction and that in this case property rights growing out of that fraud could be adjusted also. We think this is right. Jurisdiction of equity at all will hereafter he considered more in detail. If equity has jurisdiction, the demurrer should have been overruled.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit