Supreme Court of Virginia June 9, 1941, Record No. 2368 (Grandy v. Grandy)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-06-1941

Holt, J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

W. B. S. Grandy of Norfolk died on May 16, 1938, leaving to survive him a widow, Selina J. Grandy, hut no children. His last will and testament of date August 10. 1937, was duly admitted to probate on May 19, *6031938, in the Corporation Court of the city of Norfolk. By it he appointed his brother, C. W. Grandy, executor and trustee, and requested that he be permitted to qualify without security. He did qualify and in due course proceeded to have the estate of his decedent appraised.

The items which went to make up this estate were valued at these sums: Real estate, $150,747.87; intangible personal property, $527,514.23; and tangible personal property, $30.00, a total of $678,292.10.

Afterwards, and in proper time, the appellee placed his transactions before Thomas H. Willeox, Commissioner of Accounts. The settlement of that commissioner the court confirmed. By way of commissions the executor was allowed 5% of the appraised value of all intangible personal property, plus 5% on income received during the course of administration, in all $26,377.21. This the widow contends is excessive.

There was given to her the residence near Virginia Beach and tangible personalty. Other real estate the executor was to hold as trustee and to pay to her the income therefrom for life. She was also given one-half of the intangible personalty. Of that remaining one-half went to his brother, C. W. Grandy, one-fourth to his nephew, W. Selden Grandy, and one-fourth to his niece, Julia Selden Grandy. This real estate in which the widow had a life interest went at her death in fee one-half to his brother, C. W. Grandy, and one-fourth each to the named niece and nephew.

Compensation to fiduciaries is not fixed by statute and turns upon the facts in each case. It must be reasonable.

"The value of the estate, the character of the work, the difficulties encountered, and the results obtained must all be remembered in reaching a judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.