United States District Court May 22, 1941 (LaSalle Extension University v. Barr)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-05-1941

Rosenstein, J.

This action is upon a judgment rendered more than twenty years before the commencement of this action, but upon which judgment payments were made, the last being less than twenty years before such commencement. The solo question involved, therefore, is whether partial payment of a judgment operates to toll the statute of limitations. This question has not been decided in this state, and other jurisdictions, that have passed upon it, are divided.

Payment on a judgment debt suspends the running of the statute of limitations in Arkansas, Kentucky and New York. Lindsay v. Merrill, 36 Ark. 545; Koontz v. LaDow, 133 Id. 523; 202 S. W. Rep. 686; White v. Moore, 100 Ky. 358; 38 S. W. Rep. 505; In re Murray’s Estate (Court of Appeals, N. Y., 1936), 5 N. E. Rep. (2d) 717.

On the other hand, partial payment of a judgment does not suspend the running of the statute in Minnesota, North Carolina, or Ehode Island. Olson v. Dahl, 99 Minn. 433; 8 *388L. R. A. (N. S.) 444; 109 N. W. Rep. 1001; Hughes v. Boone, 114 N. C. 54; 19 S. E. Rep. 63; McDonald v. Dickson, 87 N. C. 404; McCaskill v. McKinnon, 121 N. C. 192; 28 S. E. Rep. 265; Garabedian v. Avedisian, 42 R. I. 78; 105 Atl. Rep. 516.

The conflict in the decisions as to whether the running of the statute of limitations is suspended in the case of judgments by payments on account thereof is due to the difference of opinion as to whether a judgment is a contract within the rule that payment on account of a contract tolls the statute. The better reasoned cases seem to be those holding that a judgment is not such a contract.

In Morley v. Lake Shore and Michigan Southern Railroad Co., 146 U. S. 162; 13 Sup. Ct. 54; 36 L. Ed. 925, the Supreme Court of the United States held that a judgment is not a contract within the meaning of the constitutional provision invoked by the appellant and pointed out that the most important elements of a contract are wanting.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.