New Jersey Court of Chancery May 8, 1941, Docket 129/320 (In re the Trust Created by the Liquidation & Dissolution of the Lawyers & Home-Makers Building & Loan Ass'n)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-05-1941
Stein, V. C.
The Lawyers and Home-Makers Building and Loan Association, on March 30th, 1940, sold and conveyed in bulk a substantial part of its assets pursuant to R. S. 17:12-115 and thereupon became a liquidating corporation. Thereafter several liquidating dividends were declared by the directors of the corporation but distribution of such dividends to members who had received payments on account of withdrawal of their shares after March 1st, 1933, was withheld.
The directors petitioned the court for instructions and their petition was dismissed (128 N. J. Eq. 22; 15 Atl. Rep. (2d) 137). In that suit Louis Abrams and Gaston J. Prival (shareholders) filed answer and counter-claim praying that all payments heretofore made by the association to its shareholders either as advances on account of withdrawals or as “necessitous case” payments, be set off against dividends declared and paid and to be declared and paid in the future out of the assets of the association now in liquidation.
The matter is now before me on that counter-claim actually presented as a “cross-bill.”
The counter-claimants maintain (1) that such payments created preferences in violation of the principle of equality and mutuality among shareholders, and (2) that the orders of the Commissioner of Banking and Insurance under which the “necessitous ease” payments were made are invalid.
*397Pajanen t of the withdrawal value of shares is regulated by R. S. 17:12-53. Additional powers to regulate the method of paying withdrawals and “to make orders for the purpose of conserving the assets of building and loan associations” were conferred upon the Commissioner of Banking and Insurance by R. S. App. A:7-3 to 7.
The payment of withdrawals pursuant to R. S. 17:12-53 followed the legislative scheme set down for the conduct of building and loan associations.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit