Ohio Court of Appeals October 20, 1941, No. 18260 (Drew v. Christopher Construction Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-10-1941
lead-opinion
*304OPINION
It is the opinion of the majority of this Court that the judgment rendered in this action in the Court of Common Pleas of this County should be, and the same is therefore affirmed.
LIEGHLEY, PJ., & SKEEL, J., concur.
MORGAN, J., dissents.
dissent
MORGAN, J.,
Dissenting.
Plaintiff sued to recover a judgment against the defendant on a cognovit promissory note, executed by the defendant to the plaintiff as payee, for $2450.00 being the balance of the purchase price of a house and lot sold by the plaintiff to the defendant for $15,500.00 located on Jackson Road in More-land Hills, Cuyahoga County, Ohio.
By way of answer and counterclaim, the defendant alleged that at the time of and prior to the purchase of the said house and lot by the defendant, the plaintiff, to induce the defendant to purchase the property, falsely represented and warranted to the defendant that the property had an ample water supply by way of a well supplied ■by a spring, on the premises, sufficient and fit for all household purposes; whereas in fact the water supply was not ample, which fact was known to the plaintiff or ought to have been known by him; that said well became dry in about ten days after defendant’s occupancy of the house and thereafter the property purchased had no water supply whatsoever.
That the plaintiff, after the well had gone dry, temporarily furnished water in containers and dug another well by which a sufficient volume of water was obtained, but it was and is salty and unfit for use for household purposes. That there is no way to supply water for defendant’s household except by connecting with the water system of the City of Cleveland more than two miles away, or with that of Chagrin Falls more than a mile and a quarter away, both of which methods are too costly to be practicable.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit