Supreme Court of Puerto Rico May 29, 1941, No. 8363 (Olmedo Woods v. Rivera)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-1941

Mr. Justice Todd, Jr.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

On April 18, 1941, the plaintiff appellee filed a motion for the dismissal of the appeal taken in this case, which she notified to the defendants appellants on the same date and whose hearing was set for May 26, last.

On the day of the hearing, appellants filed a motion “for the removal from the record of a pleading of the appellee and requesting the striking out of certain irrelevant matter. ’ ’ The parties were heard on this motion and we continued the hearing on the motion to dismiss the appeal.

Appellants request to have stricken from the record the two paragraphs of appellee’s motion which read as follows:

“That in the meantime, after the hearing had been held in the lower court on January 27, 1941, but before the lion. Jorge L. 'Cordova had rendered his judgment, the defendant Philip El Koury, through his counsel E. Martinez Rivera, filed with the Clerk of the 'Court, without notifying the plaintiff or her lawyer, — and in a manner so surreptitious and collusive that he succeeded in getting the ■clerk to disregard the established practice of notifying the order of the court to the other party — a motion wherein, without due respect to the court, he stated the falsity that ‘the court had rendered judgment in this case dismissing the complaint in all its parts; that this judgment was final, and that the cancellation of the lis pendens, recorded in the books of the Registry of Property, should be effected.’

“To this motion the judge, Hon. R. La Costa Jr., taken by surprise or relying in the honorability of the lawyer, provided ‘as requested’ ; to a motion whose prayer involved the issuance of a warrant to the registrar ordering him to cancel a lis pendens entered on the margin of the record of a property in controversy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.