Supreme Court of Puerto Rico June 24, 1941, No. 78 (Jiménez Ramos v. District Court of Humacao)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-06-1941

Mr. Justice Todd, Jr.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

Petitioner herein has asked ns. to reconsider onr order of June 20, 1941, whereby we refused to issue the writ of prohibition sought by him on that same day, to prevent the District Court of Humacao from compelling him to appear on June 23, 1941, for his arraignment in a prosecution for voluntary manslaughter instituted against him in said court. The only ground alleged by petitioner for the granting of the above writ is that he personally had subscribed and filed in the lower court a paper writing in which he waived the arraignment, as he had a copy of the information and knew its contents, pleaded not guilty, and asked for a jury trial. He also set forth his personal circumstances. As already stated, said paper writing was subscribed by the petitioner personally without being represented by counsel.

In the petition for the issuance of the writ of prohibition it is set forth that compelling the defendant to appear to be arraigned, after he had waived such right, constitutes “an appearance which is manifestly unnecessary, vexatious, and in every way useless,” and that if he fails to appear “in order to avoid the unpleasantness of an unnecessary vexation,” he would be punished for contempt against said court.

Although we are not bound to explain the reasons for our refusal to issue an extraordinary writ of this court, we will say that the fact that the petition was decided without delivering an opinion was due to the delay of the peti*31tioner in waiting to file bis petition until three days before the day set for the appearance of the defendant in the conrt below, of which three days one and a half were holidays. For onr order to be of any effect it had to be made forthwith. -It is alleged in the motion for reconsideration that the hearing in the conrt below has been continued to June 30, 1941.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.