District Court, E.D. Michigan June 11, 1941, Civil Action No. 1241 (Schram v. Safety Inv. Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-06-1941
PICARD, District Judge.
The facts in this case are not disputed. Plaintiff claims title to certain real property through foreclosure of a mortgage and defendant by virtue of title emanating from a Detroit city tax sale in March 1931.
The main question involved is whether the Detroit city charter by fair interpretation requires that each parcel of land to be sold as tax delinquent be separately described in the published notice and if it does not so provide does such failure render any tax sale under it absolutely void. It is conceded that the Detroit charter as it existed prior to 1935 does not specify publication of a description of each parcel in like language as the State of Michigan was obligated to do under the General Property Tax. That charter merely required the City Treasurer to publish a notice to tax payers of delinquent tax sales including a statement that a list had been prepared of such taxpayers delinquent in special tax assessments “for sidewalks, tree planting, sewers, street paving, alley paving, street openings and widenings, alley openings and widenings, and water pipe extensions.” The notice of the City Treasurer also al*520ways stated that personal notice by letter with bills rendered had “been sent to all owners” etc.
However, there was evidence that prior to 1930 the procedure followed by the Detroit Treasurer was identical with that of the State’s Auditor General, but this practice was discontinued at the beginning of die depression and in 1935 the procedure that had been followed, either voluntarily or by interpretation up to 1930, was specifically written into the law.
The owner, in this action, had failed to pay his street paving tax and the sale here was held in 1931.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit