United States Customs Court August 28, 1942, No. 47518 (Protests 935121-G of Abeling)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-08-1942

Opinion by

Keefe, J.

At the trial the testimony showed that due to a shipping strike at the port of entry (San Francisco), there were no facilities for handling the merchandise upon the wharves because of the congestion. A conference was held between the importer and the customs officials to determine the course of procedure to adopt under the circumstances and it was agreed, inasmuch as a dock examination was impossible, that the cases be taken under customs seal to the importer’s warehouse for examination; that the seals be broken there, the cases opened, and the glass examined; that when all of the breakage was determined the customs officials would make their final report; that the entries were to be withheld until the final report of breakage was filed; and that no credit would be given the customers of the importer for breakage until the amounts had been approved by the customs officials. Several of the witnesses testifying at the trial were those present at the conference. When this final report of breakage was' received, the importer testified he turned it over to one of the examiners.

Attached to the appraiser’s letter requesting an investigation appeared copies of two reports of breakage, which were received in evidence as exhibits 4 and 5. The customs agent made an investigation and several exhibits were received in evidence in connection therewith. It appeared that an error in computation was discovered in one of the exhibits. A stipulation was entered into between counsel correcting the error in exhibit 5. It appeared that upon examination by the interested parties considerable broken glass was found and that because of congestion in the importer’s warehouse, it was agreed between the parties that an estimate of the quantity of damage could be made. Therefore, the broken glass was not weighed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.