Supreme Court of the United States February 8, 1943, 214 (Michigan v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-02-1943

Mr. Chief Justice Stone

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This is a companion case to

Detroit Bank

v.

United States, ante,

p. 329. It involves the lien for estate taxes asserted by the Government and considered in our opinion in that case.

Petitioners, the City of Detroit, the County of Wayne, and the State of Michigan, assert liens for city, county and state taxes on the real estate in question, accruing subsequent to the federal estate tax lien. As defendants in the suit brought by the Government to foreclose the lien, they attack it on all the grounds considered and rejected in our opinion in the

Detroit Bank

case. They also contend that the state liens are given superiority over the federal lien by virtue of state statutes. Section 3429 of the Compiled Laws of Michigan, 1929, as amended by Act No. 38 of the Extra Session of 1934, declares that taxes “shall become a lien upon such real property” on specified dates following their assessment and, as construed by petitioners, states that they shall be a “first lien, prior, superior, and paramount.” Section 3746 authorizes the filing of notice of liens as provided in R. S. § 3186, in the offices of registers

*340

of deeds in the counties of Michigan. Petitioners contend that these and other statutory provisions as construed by Michigan courts give superiority to state tax liens over other unrecorded liens, including the present estate tax lien of the federal Government.

We do not stop to inquire whether this construction of the state statutes is the correct one, for we think the argument ignores the effect of a lien for federal taxes under the supremacy clause of the Constitution. The establishment • of a tax lien by Congress is an exercise of its constitutional power “to lay and collect taxes.” Article I, § 8 of the Constitution.

United States

v.

Snyder,

149 U. S. 210.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.