Arizona Supreme Court October 11, 1943, Civil No. 4147. (Burton v. Valentine)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-10-1943
STANFORD, J.
This is a breach of promise case brought for $50,000. It was tried before a jury in the Superior Court in Phoenix, Maricopa County. A verdict of $5,000 was awarded appellee.
Charles E. Burton was a well-known livestock man with interests mainly in Northern Arizona. He was a married man in the year of 1930, at the time the parties to this action first met, but was not living with his wife and was divorced from his wife, Mabel Frankfurter Burton, in California on October 31,1932.
Appellee was the wife of Carl A. Valentine and lived with her husband at Grand Canyon, Arizona. She remained his wife until their divorce, August 20, 1931.
The parties herein first met at a country dance near Flagstaff, Arizona, in July, 1930.
It is important that we quote part of the short complaint and answer in this cause.
Quoting from appellee’s first amended complaint:
“II. That during the month of December, 1930, in consideration of a proposal of marriage from the defendant, the plaintiff accepted said proposal and agreed to marry the defendant.
‘ ‘ III. That thereafter said promise of marriage was renewed by the defendant from time to time.
*520
“IV. That during the month of December, 1932, at Phoenix, Arizona, in consideration of an agreement by plaintiff then and there made that the plaintiff, who was then unmarried, would marry the defendant within a reasonable time, the defendant, who was then also unmarried, renewed his said promise to marry the plaintiff within a reasonable time.
“V. That thereafter said defendant postponed the marriage from time to time but continued to renew said promise of marriage on occasions too numerous to set forth herein with any particularity, and without fixing any definite date.
“VI.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit