New York Court of Appeals April 15, 1943 (People v. Flynn)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1943
Loughran, J.
The defendant has been convicted of murder in the first degree.
On the night of January 21, 1940, he entered a bar and grill in the city of New York intending to commit robbery therein. Among the patrons who were in the place at the time were Claude Phelps and Oscar Ryan. Brandishing a revolver, the defendant said: “This is a stick-up. Get in the back.” Ryan was a police officer but was not wearing his uniform. He drew his service revolver which chanced to be unloaded. Thereupon the defendant fired a stray shot and at once backed out of the place. Phelps and officer Ryan followed after him. As they reached the street, he fired another shot from behind an automobile he had parked there. The death of Phelps was the instantaneous result, i
These undisputed facts eoncededly proved guilt of criminal homicide in some degree. With the consent of both sides, the court ruled that the killing was not felony murder. (Penal Law, § 1044, subd. 2.) This was in the absence of the jury. No mention of felony murder was made in -the summations of counsel or in the charge of the trial judge. He defined the crime of true murder in the first degree (Penal Law, § 1044, subd. 1) and then read to the jury from
People
v.
Majone
(91 N. Y. 211) as follows: “Under the statute there must be not only an intention to kill, but there must also be a deliberate and premeditated design to kill. Such design must precede the killing by some appreciable space of time. But the time need not be long. It must be sufficient for some reflection or consideration upon the
*223
matter, for, choice to kill or not to kill, and for the formation of a definite purpose to kill. The human mind acts with • celerity which it is sometimes impossible to measure, and whether a deliberate or
*
premeditated design to Mil was formed must be determined from all the circumstances of the case.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit