New York County Courts October 27, 1943 (People v. Paterno)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-10-1943
Ottaway, J.
The defendant pleaded guilty in County Court of this county to a charge of robbery in the second degree. At the time of sentence he also admitted that he was the same person who was, on July 16, 1937, convicted in Erie County of the crime of attempted- grand larceny in the second degree. On .this earlier conviction he had received a suspended sentence. In. our court, on the charge of robbery in the second degree, defendant was sentenced as a second offender. He now seeks an order for his return to court and for resentence, asserting that the conviction in Erie County is void.
It is claimed that defendant was originally charged in Erie County with receiving stolen property; that on arraignment the District Attorney moved to reduce the charge to attempted grand larceny in the second degree; that the motion was granted, the charge reduced, a plea of guilty to the reduced charge entered, and defendant given a suspended sentence.
Defendant now urges that the procedure on this conviction in Erie County was irregular and the conviction void as attempted grand larceny in the second degree cannot be con*493sidered a lesser degree of the crime with which he was first indicted (receiving stolen property).
There is, of course, precedent for his interpretation of the law governing pleas to lesser degrees of the same crime. Whether it is applicable here we do not decide but address ourselves to the more important question of whether a county court (a court of limited jurisdiction) may pass upon the validity of a judgment of conviction in another court of record of this State.
It is a basic rule of law that the judgment of a court of record shall not be subject to collateral attack. Our Code of Criminal Procedure states an application of this principle in section 515, where it is provided that “ hereafter the only mode of reviewing a judgment or order in a criminal action or proceeding, or special proceeding of a criminal nature, is by appeal.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit