District Court, D. Minnesota April 29, 1944, Civil Action 315 (Griesedieck Western Brewery Co. v. Peoples Brewing Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-04-1944

JOYCE, District Judge.

4'his is a suit for equitable relief for infringement of plaintiff’s registered trademark and copyrighted label. There was also an allegation of unfair competition, but on the trial this was unsupported by proof. We are concerned only with the first two grounds mentioned.

Plaintiff is an Illinois corporation with its principal place of business in that state. It operates a brewery and since 1908 has sold beer in interstate commerce under the trade-mark “Stag.” It is the owner of certificate of registration No. 320,594 registered January 1, 1935, under the Act of February 20, 1905, 15 U.S.C.A. § 81 et seq. Plaintiff is also the owner of “Stag” label copyrights dated March 10, 1908, and June 23, 1936, under U.S.C.A. Title 17. Plaintiff markets its beer in some thirteen states all of which are in a trade area extending south and west of Illinois. With the exception of Iowa, it has not sold its product

*602

in any state contiguous to Minnesota. It has never sold beer in Minnesota, solicited business, advertised, or contracted in this state.

Defendant is a' Minnesota corporation with its principal place of business in Duluth. It is also a brewery and in 1938 started to market beer under the name “Stag” using a label with a deer or elk’s head not dissimilar to that used by plaintiff on its trade-mark and copyrighted label. -There is no showing that defendant intentionally appropriated the mark and label of plaintiff; in fact, the contrary appears.

There is no competition in any state or in any trading area between plaintiff and defendant at the present time, nor has there been any such, nor is there any showing that such competition is imminent. Defendant has not gone beyond the Duluth trading area, and plaintiff’s expansion has been entirely south and west from Illinois and not into the northern states at all.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.