Supreme Court of Florida November 7, 1944 (Hillyer & Lovan v. Florida Industrial Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-11-1944

ADAMS, J.:

Robert Christopher lost his life under" circumstances whereby a claim for compensation was appropriate únder our Workmen’s Compensation Act. A claim was made by Lena Christopher, who will be referred to as wife number one. A claim was also made by her child by Robert Christopher. A claim was filed by Alma Christopher, who will be referred to * as wife number two.

Deceased was duly married to wife number one in 1923. There were frequent separations until September, 1941, when they separated the last time and thereafter they did not live together.

Wife number two was married to Christopher in January, 1942, and lived with him until his death in December, 1942.

■ The deputy commissioner took considerable tetsimony and concluded that wife number one was not dependent on Chris

*145

topher for support; that she was not living apart from him through his fault and denied her claim. * He also found that wife number two could not sustain her claim because Christopher had never been divorced from wife number one. He ■allowed compensation to the minor child.

The Commission reversed that part of the order denying the claim of wife number two and allowed her compensation and an attorney’s fee.

On further review by the circuit court, Judge DeWitt T. Gray, affirmed the commission’s order and allowed an additional counsel fee of $300.00 to be paid by the employer and carrier.

The employer and carrier have appealed. The first question for us to decide is whether appellants can prosecute this appeal and thereby further litigate the question of who is the widow inasmuch as neither wife is now questioning the decision rendered by the circuit court.

It is earnestly claimed that the question of marriage vel non is purely an incidental question and not subject to question by the carrier in this fashion as it would be a collateral attack. The case of Lovejoy Co., et al., v. Ackis, 153 Fla. 876, 16 So.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.