Court of Appeals of Georgia February 4, 1944, 30398. (Graham v. Hall)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-1944

Sutton, P. J.

This was a proceeding by

W.

H. Hall to foreclose a laborer’s lien against Mamie Graham, returnable to the March quarterly term, 1942, of the city court of Dublin. The case came on for trial at the September quarterly term, 1943, and after the introduction of evidence, a verdict and judgment were rendered in favor of the plaintiff. The defendant made a motion for a new trial, which was overruled on October 26, 1943. It is recited in the bill of exceptions that when the case came on for trial, counsel for the defendant made a motion for a continuance, based on a doctor’s certificate to the effect that the defendant was then and had been in the doctor’s hospital for two days with a severe headache and high blood pressure, and that she could not appear in court without jeopardizing her present condition; and her counsel stated that he was unable to go to trial without his client. It is also recited that the plaintiff introduced evidence on the motion to continue, and that after hearing the evidence, the court overruled the motion. Error is assigned in the bill of exceptions on the overruling of the motion to continue, but no error is assigned on the verdict or judgment in favor of the plaintiff, or on the judgment overruling the motion for a new. trial. No brief of the evidence introduced upon the trial of the case accompanied the motion for a new trial, nor was the evidence set out in the bill of exceptions.

It has been held many times by this court and the Supreme Court that one of the indispensable requisites of a valid motion for a new trial'is that it be accompanied by a brief of the evidence. “If there is no brief of the evidence, no motion for a new trial ex

*598

ists.”

Whitaker

v.

State,

138

Ga.

139 (75 S. E. 254);

Baker

v.

Johnson,

99

Ga.

374 (27 S. E. 706);

Lucas

v.

Lucas,

179

Ga.

821 (177 S. E. 684);

Butler

v.

Jaques & Tinsley Co.,

31

Ga. App.

74 (119 S. E. 469);

Dunn

v.

Goodrich Rubber Co.,

32

Ga. App.

202 (122 S. E. 793);

Baggett

v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.