Supreme Court of North Carolina September 20, 1944 (Lindsey v. . Speight)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-09-1944
*454
Stacy, C. J.
After abandoning bis allegations of special contract, the plaintiff recovered in the court below on
quantum meruit
or for the reasonable value of his services. This is permissible under our practice.
Lipe v. Trust Co.,
206 N. C., 24, 173 S. E., 316;
Hayman v. Davis,
182 N. C., 563, 109 S. E., 554;
Bryan v. Cowles,
152 N. C., 767, 68 S. E., 205;
Reams v. Wilson,
147 N. C., 304, 60 S. E., 1124. In
Grantham v. Grantham,
205 N. C., 363, 171 S. E., 331, the plaintiff declared on a special contract, void under the statute of frauds, and was allowed to recover in
assumpsit on quantum meruit.
The procedure also finds support in what was said in
Lipe v. Trust Co.,
207 N. C., 794, 178 S. E., 665.
For about three years, the defendant, W. L. Speight, had been trying to sell his wife's farm in Edgecombe County. He spoke to C. J. Weeks about it on several occasions. Weeks offered him $13,500 for the farm, which he refused. On 18 October, 1943, Speight listed the property with the brokerage firm of R. A. Lindsey
&
Company for sale at $15,000. Lindsey approached Weeks about a sale, and Weeks said he would give $100 an acre for 135 acres. This was the same offer which he had previously made to Speight and which Speight had rejected. Lindsey communicated Weeks’ offer to Speight and recommended its acceptance. Speight did not commit himself at the time. On a second occasion Weeks told Lindsey he would pay $13,500 for the farm, if it had a tobacco allotment of 7% acres, and would keep his offer good if the allotment were increased to 10 acres. This was communicated to Speight, who said he thought he could get the allotment increased. The next thing Lindsey knew of the matter Speight had sold to Weeks for $13,500.
The defendants concede, in their brief, that
Lindsey’s
testimony, standing alone, may be sufficient to justify the jury in finding “Lindsey .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit