Supreme Court of Pennsylvania December 1, 1944, Appeal, 238 (Kurman v. Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-12-1944

Opinion by

Me. Chief Justice Maxey,

This is an appeal from the order of the court below dismissing an appeal of the plaintiffs from the action of the Bureau of Engineering, Surveys and Zoning in refusing the plaintiffs a “use registration permit” or “certificate of variance” to authorize the plaintiffs’ use of premises at 5831 Drexel Road, Philadelphia, as a place for conducting religious services over each weekend.

As the court below said: “The facts are not in dispute and the questions raised by the facts are whether it was necessary for the plaintiffs to obtain the Board’s permission and, if so, whether the Board properly exercised its discretion in refusing permission.” President Judge Finlettee succinctly stated the facts and formulated the issue in this case as follows:

“Joseph Kurman, one of the appellants, is a rabbi of the Jewish Orthodox faith and the owner of the said premises, a detached building located in a district classified as ‘A’ Residential under the Zoning Ordinance. This building was designed for use as a dwelling and has been so used in the past. On April 30, 1943, Rabbi Kurman applied for and obtained a permit to use his premises as a one-family dwelling and as an office for him as a rabbi. Under this permit he used a room in his house as a meeting place for children whom he instructed in religious matters. He also organized a church group under the name of Congregation Toras Chaim and conducted services over each weekend.

“The Philadelphia Zoning Ordinance of August 10, 1933, provides in section 7 that buildings in an ‘A’ residential District may be used, inter alia, as ‘(1) Detached single-family dwellings. ... (2) Churches, chapels or other places of worship.’ Combinations of these two uses are neither listed

nor expressly prohibited,

and

*249

should a building meet all the requirements for both types of uses as set forth elsewhere in the ordinance, no reason appears why such a building could not be used for both purposes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.