Court of Appeals of Texas December 21, 1944, No. 4270. (State Ex Rel. City of Jasper v. Gulf States Utilities Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-12-1944
COE, Chief Justice.
This suit was instituted by the State of Texas, acting by and through the attorney general of Texas, upon the relation of the City of Jasper, appellant herein, against the Gulf States Utilities Company, a Texas Corporation, appellee, in the nature of a quo warranto proceeding to test the right of the utility company to use the streets and alleys of the City of Jasper for the purpose of distributing electricity to the public for profit. A jury being waived, the cause was tried to the court who found for the defendant, from which judgment the plaintiff has perfected this appeal
Appellant urges this court to reverse and render this cause on two propositions, which are substantially as follows: (1) That the purported franchise granted by the Commissioners’ Court of Jasper County to ap-pellee’s predecessors, under authority of which appellee now claims a right to use the streets and alleys of the City of Jasper to distribute electricity to the public for
*502
profit, is' void because the Commissioners’ Court was without power or authority to grant the same, and (2) that the Gulf States Utilities Company now has no authority to use the streets and alleys of the City of Jasper to distribute electricity to the public for profit.
The appellee counters with some thirteen counterpoints, the first being in substance that the appellant’s pleadings were insufficient as a basis for the relief prayed for in that it did not neg'ative every reasonable inference arising upon the facts as alleged, such as acquiesence by affirmative acts, ratification, estoppel and laches. We are of the opinion that appellant’s petition was sufficient to plead a cause of action in this character of case, the injunc-tive features of this suit being only ancillary to the quo warranto proceeding. The strict rules applicable to petitions for injunctions and mandamus do not apply. See 51 C.J. 345.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit