Court of Appeals of Texas February 4, 1944, No. 13475. (London Terrace, Inc. v. McAlister)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-02-1944
lead-opinion
LOONEY, Justice.
London. Terrace, Inc., a New York corporation, owner of a large apartment building located in the Borough of Manhattan, New York City, sued Raymond W. Mc-Alister to recover balance claimed to be due on a lease contract. Plaintiff appealed from an adverse judgment based''upon findings of a jury. -The material facts are these; Plaintiff leased to the defendant an apartment for the period of two years;
*516
defendant paid rent for IS months, but refused to make further payments and abandoned the premises, claiming that plaintiff breached its obligation to keep the apartment sufficiently and comfortably heated as the weather conditions required.
Defendant specially plead that before signing the lease contract, plaintiff, through an authorized agent, “represented and covenanted with defendant that the premises leased would always have steam heat available”; that when the previously prepared lease contract was presented for execution, defendant said he would obtain the advice of his attorney before signing, but being assured by plaintiff’s representative that the written contract contained nothing in derogation of the verbal representations and obligations, defendant signed without reading; that the verbal representations were fraudulently made, without any intention on the part of plaintiff to comply with same, they were fraudulently omitted from the written contract, and that plaintiff failed to comply with its verbal covenant to properly heat the premises. Defendant plead and rested his defense exclusively on the issue of fraud as above set out, and the case was submitted by the court to the jury on that theory, which, for reasons hereinafter stated, we have concluded was error, and under our view of the case it will not be necessary to determine whether or not defendant was negligent in not reading the contract before signing.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit