Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 15, 1944 (In re Holman)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1944

Heffernan, J.

In 1927 the appellant instituted a condemnation proceeding in the Warren County Court for the purpose of acquiring title to a small portion of land belonging to Pauline Newton for the construction of a public highway.

The court appointed commissioners to ascertain the compensation to be made to the owner of the property.

Thereafter hearings were held and the commissioners made a report dated October 26, 1927, awarding the landowner $2,550. This report was confirmed by the court on October 31, 1927, and the order of confirmation directed the County Treasurer to pay to the owner the amount of the award together with costs. The County Treasurer complied with the court’s order.

At the time the proceeding was instituted and when the award was made and confirmed the entire tract of land owned by Pauline Newton, of which the portion taken for highway purposes was a part, was subject to the lien of two mortgages, one dated March 30, 1908, and recorded in the Warren County clerk’s office on September 8, 1908, and one dated July 1, 1909, and recorded in the same clerk’s office on July 31, 1909.

Through various assignments respondent has become the owner of these two mortgages which are still unsatisfied.

Eespondent’s predecessors in title to these mortgages were not made parties to the condemnation proceeding and neither the original mortgagees nor their successors in interest have released their claim to the award.

The mortgagees are included within the term “ owner ” (Condemnation Law, § 2) and hence they were not only proper but necessary parties in the proceeding (Condemnation Law. § 4). The order of confirmation has no binding force on them The term “ owner ” when employed in statutes relating to eminent domain to designate the persons who are to be made parties to the proceeding, refers, as is the rule in respect of those entitled to compensation, to all those who have any lawful interest in the property to be condemned.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.