Superior Court of Pennsylvania September 24, 1945, Appeals, 22 and 24 (Commonwealth v. Lemley)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-09-1945
Opinion by
Baldrige, P. J.,
The question presented in this appeal is whether in a criminal case the commonwealth has the right to have the jury polled after a sealed verdict has been offered in open court?
*126
Raymond Lemley, the appellant herein, was charged with the crimes of (1) public indecency, and (2) assault and battery. The jury retired in the afternoon and about four hours thereafter handed to the attending tipstaff two sealed verdicts. The next morning when the court reconvened, according to a statement of Judge Egan who presided at the trial, the sealed verdicts finding the defendant “not guilty” were handed to the court clerk and after examination by the trial judge were read aloud by the clerk. The district attorney immediately made a motion to poll the jury, which was done. The poll disclosed that the jurors were not in agreement, some answering “Guilty” and others “Not Guilty.” The trial judge refused to accept the verdicts as returned, ordered that they be not recorded, and declared a mistrial in both cases. The defendant thereupon petitioned the court to grant a rule to show cause why the verdicts of the jury as presented should not be reinstated. The petition was discharged and thereupon this appeal was taken.
Undoubtedly, it is too late to ask a jury to be polled where a verdict has been announced in open court, affirmed by the jury and
recorded.
Until the verdict is recorded it is of no force, as it is not the legal verdict of a jury:
Rottmund v. Pennsylvania Railroad Company,
225 Pa. 410, 416, 74 A. 341. We are not aware, however, of any case squarely deciding that a request by the district attorney to poll a jury before a verdict is received and recorded shall be granted. But textbook authorities generally recognize that either the commonwealth or defendant has a right to have a jury polled on the rendering of the verdict, whether oral or sealed, at any time before it is recorded: Abbott’s Criminal Trial Practice, 4th Ed., 1939, §735, p. 1382.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit