Superior Court of Pennsylvania October 22, 1945, Appeals, 86 and 87 (Commonwealth v. Morrison)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-10-1945

Opinion by

Dithrich, J.,

Appellant was convicted of the crime of sodomy on September 16, 1944. An appeal was taken to this court and the convictions (on two indictments) were affirmed in an opinion by Judge Reno.

(Com. v.

Morrison, 157

*312

Pa. Superior Ct. 366, 43 A. 2d 400.) A petition for an appeal to the Supreme Court was dismissed. On September 13, 1945, before the Supreme Court had acted on the petition, appellant filed a petition in the court below for a writ of error

coram nobis.

Attached to the petition was the statement of one Mrs. Alice Smith, a member of the jury which tried Morrison. The writ was refused on the following day in an opinion filed by the court below. On September 20, 1945, the Commonwealth filed its answer to the petition for writ of

coram nobis.

After the appellant brought this appeal from the order refusing the writ, the Commonwealth filed an additional answer

nunc pro tunc.

To the additional answer there is also attached a statement by Mrs. Smith. Neither answer was considered by the court below when it refused to grant the writ. Both answers are certified to this court and printed as part of the record.

The petition for the writ alleges improper interference and tampering with the jury, and refers, to the exhibit attached, Mrs. Smith’s statement. Her statement says that the eight women on the jury were dominated by the four men, that after the jury retired, the jurors “. . . wished to get it over with so as to get dinner, . . .” and that

“. . .

one of the men on the jury said he was talking to a fellow in a hotel who said Morrison was guilty and if we did not bring in a verdict of guilty we ought to be hung.” The additional answer to the petition contains a second statement by Mrs. Smith in which she explains the circumstances under which the first statement was made and makes certain corrections.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.