Supreme Court of Florida October 1, 1946 (Stanley v. Campbell)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-10-1946

BUFORD, J.:

The appeal is from final decree adjudicating a deed conveying real estate to be void because the grantor was insane at the time of the transaction and the execution of the deed.

Grantor was adjudged insane by order of County Judge of Dade County on July 21st 1931 and again on April 23rd 1937 and again on March 8th 1944. Guardian of the person and estate of grantor, adjudged to be an insane person, was appointed by the County Judge of Dade County on the 9th day of August, 1935. The guardianship of the grantor continued until after the date of the transaction here involved.

On February 14th 1944 grantor, D. D. Campbell, then being at liberty, but when there had been by a court of competent jurisdiction no judgment or decree restoring him to a sound mental condition, made and executed the deed which the court below held to be void.

The last adjudication of the lunacy of the grantor and his commitment thereunder was made and entered twenty-two days after the execution of the deed.

*892

Unquestionably, at the time of the execution of the deed the grantor must' be presumed to have been insane. See Kuehmsted v. Turnwall, 115 Fla. 692, 155 So. 847; Bassett v. Federal Land Bank of Columbia, 98 Fla. 266, 123 So. 732.

When the grantor’s sanity was brought into question and the above state of facts was shown to exist it became encumbent on one claiming under a conveyance made under such circumstances to show that the grantor was sane and competent to transact his affairs and to protect his own interest at the time of the execution of the conveyance. See Kuehmsted v. Turnwall, supra, and cases there cited.

After the issues were made up in this case and the testimony taken, the Chancellor inter alia, found:

“(g) That said D. D. Campbell was insane and mentally incapable of determining the effect of the sale of his said property on February 5, 1944, the date of said sale, and on February 14, 1944, the date of the execution and delivery of his deed to said property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.