Supreme Court of New Hampshire February 11, 1946, No. 3533. (Scott v. Davis)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-02-1946

Marble, C. J.

The decision of the city government to make the change in the ordinance which Mr. Davis requested was subject to the statutory right of any taxpayer to appeal therefrom within thirty days. R. L., c. 51, s. 64.

While ordinarily a court is not authorized to substitute its judgment for that of either a city government or a board of adjustment (38 Mich. Law Rev. 431, 432, and authorities cited in note 4;

Zahn

v.

Board,

274 U. S. 325, 328), we believe that the Superior Court was so authorized under sections 64 to 69 of the Zoning Act (R. L.,

c.

51). We have already so held in relation to the decisions of boards of adjustment.

Vogel

v.

Board,

92 N. H. 195.

The form of the Zoning Act, when first introduced in the Senate of 1925 as Senate Bill No. 16, was that of the “Standard Enabling Act” (see Metzenbaum, “Law of Zoning,” 303, 309). What is now section 64 related in first draft merely to the decisions of boards of adjustment, but was amended to include “any decision of the legislative body” of a municipality “in regard to its plan of zoning,” and what is now section 65, entitled “Appeals to Court,” was substituted for the original provision allowing writs of

certiorari.

Since no provision limiting the extent of the court’s revisory power appears in the act, we believe that it was the legislative intent to treat both appeals, whether from the decisions of boai’ds of adjustment or from the decisions of city governments, on precisely the same basis. This being so, the rule of the

Vogel

case is applicable.

At the hearing before the city government the appellees (Mr. Davis and those associated with him) assumed the burden of proving a public need for the amendment in question, and inasmuch as an appeal is merely a continuation of the original proceeding, they were required to assume that burden in the Superior Court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.