Supreme Court of Alabama February 6, 1947, 6 Div. 493. (Jefferson Standard Life Ins. Co. v. Wigley)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-02-1947

*678

STAKELY, Justice.

This is a suit brought by Ida Leola Sterling Wigley (appellee) against Jefferson Standard Life Insurance Company (appellant) on a policy of life insurance in the principal sum of $2500. The policy was issued by appellant on September 15, 1939, on the life of Perry Braswell Wigley and is payable to Ida Leola Sterling Wigley, his wife, as beneficiary. The insured, Perry Braswell Wigley, died on August 30, 1940.

The defense in this case is death of the insured by suicide with no liability by reason of the following clause contained in the policy: “In case of self-destruction committed, whether sane or insane, within two full years from the date hereof, the extent of recovery hereunder shall be the premiums paid.”

Trial of the case resulted in a verdict and judgment for the plaintiff. In its oral charge the court charged, in effect, that there is a presumption that a normal, sane person will not commit suicide. The defendant excepted to this portion of the court’s oral charge and this presents the controlling question on this appeal. In the case of Fleetwood v. Pacific Mut. Life Ins. Co., 246 Ala. 571, 21 So.2d 696, 698, 159 A.L.R. 171, this court, after reviewing the Alabama authorities, said: “That there are situations when the presumption is applicable and on the contrary, there are situations when the presumption has no field " of operation.” From the Alabama authorities this court laid dow-n the following rules: “If there is direct and positive evidence of suicide and there is no conflicting inference from any evidence as to suicide,- then the presumption against suicide has no field of operation. On the contrary, if there is direct and positive evidence of suicide and there is a conflicting inference from any evidence as to suicide, then the presumption against suicide has a field of operation. If the evidence is all circumstantial, then the presumption against suicide has a field of operation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.