Supreme Court of North Carolina November 19, 1947 (Randle Ex Rel. Love v. Grady)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-11-1947

Defendants’ Appeal.

Winbobne, J.

While consideration of tbe several exceptions assigned by defendants as errors on their appeal fail to show reversible error, we treat them

seriatim:

1. Tbe first four exceptions relate to deposition of tbe cashier of a bank in Knoxville, Tennessee, wbicb plaintiff offered in evidence. Tbe sufficiency of tbe deposition, as stated in brief of defendants, is questioned (1) because of tbe way and manner in wbicb it was returned to tbe Clerk of tbe Superior Court, and (2) because of tbe failure of tbe Clerk to pass upon and allow it. As to tbe first, it appears from tbe evidence set out in tbe case on appeal that after tbe deposition bad been taken it was put in an envelope of tbe attorney for plaintiff, wbicb bad been prepared in bis office in Asheville, North Carolina. Tbe notary public sealed and stamped tbe envelope, and requested tbe attorney to drop it in tbe mail wben be reached Asheville, and be did as requested. Tbe • statute, G. S., 8-71, provides that “depositions shall be subscribed and sealed up by tbe commissioners or notary public, and returned to tbe court, tbe Clerk whereof . . . shall open and pass upon tbe same . . .” How it shall be returned is not prescribed. But in this case tbe method pursued is conceded to be free from cause for complaint. As to tbe second, tbe record fails to show any objection, exception or assignment of error. Moreover, while tbe record shows that tbe exception taken to tbe exhibits attached to tbe deposition is assigned as error, no argument in reference thereto is made in tbe brief filed here. Hence, it is taken as abandoned by him. Rule 28 of tbe Rules of Practice in tbe Supreme Court of North Carolina, 221 N. C., 544.

*163

2. The fifth exception is to the overruling of defendants’ objection to the introduction of a portion of the agreed case on appeal from the Buncombe County Court to the Superior Court of Buncombe County in the case of Harold K. Bennett, Guardian of Eunice E.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.