Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit December 4, 1947, No. 11992 (Bennett v. Great American Indemnity Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-12-1947
LEE, Circuit Judge.
This is a workman’s compensation case under the Texas statute, Rev.Civ.Stat. art. 8301 et seq., Vernon’s Ann.Civ.St.Tex. art. 8301 et seq. Appellant Lester Bennett alleged that he was an employee of Shaw & Estes, general contractors, insured under the act with defendant, Great American Indemnity Company, appellee; that in the course of his employment, on August, 31, 1945, the scaffold on which he was working fell and he sustained injuries to his right arm, shoulder, neck, and back; and that those injuries have permanently disabled him for labor. Appellant had filed a claim with the Industrial Accident Board on March 14, 1946, which was denied. At the conclusion of the evidence, the court granted defendant’s motion for an instructed verdict. Judgment was rendered for defendant on February 10, 1947.
On appeal, appellant’s specifications of error are that the court erred in holding there was no evidence showing or tending to show that appellant had good cause for his failure to file his claim within the statutory period; and that the court erred in holding that the evidence showed conclusively and as a matter of law that appellant was an independent contractor and not an employee of Shaw & Estes; and that the court erred in sustaining appellee’s, motion for an instructed verdict.
To take the second specification first, appellant’s regular business was that of a brick contractor. The men under him were hired by him, paid by him, and worked under his instructions. He paid the Social Security taxes on the wages of his men. There is some evidence to show that appellant himself was under the supervision of the superintendent of the general contractors, but the evidence as a whole justifies but one inference, and that is that the supervision extended only to the point of seeing that the work done by the appellant and his men was in accordance with the plans and specifications. Cf. Blankenship v. Royal Ind. Co., Tex. Com-App., 95 S.W.2d 366, 368.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit