Supreme Court of Puerto Rico July 11, 1947, No. 9519 (Rosario Martínez v. Suárez Pérez)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-07-1947

'Mr. Justice 'Todd, Jr.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This is a case of involuntary acknowledgment of natural ^children and of maintenance and support. The District Court of San Juan sustained the complaint as to both causes of action. Regarding the one of filiation, the court in its judgment said:

“Juan, Héctor Luis, Miguel Ángel, and Luisa, born on November .26, 1924, May 21, 1928, June 15, 1938, and August 25, 1939, .respectively, are hereby declared acknowledged natural children of •defendant, Juan Suárez Pérez, pursuant to the provisions of paragraph two of § 2 of Act No. 229 of May 12, 1942 (Laws of 1942, p. 1296), as amended by § 2 of Act No. 243, of May 12, 1945 (Laws of 1945, p. 814).”1

It further ordered the defendant to pay plaintiffs a monthly allowance of $94 for the support of her three minor *554children, Héctor Luis, Miguel Ángel, and Luisa2 and $350 as attorney’s fees.

Feeling aggrieved, the defendant appealed. He urges that the lower court erred, first, in declaring Juan Rosario an acknowledged natural son of defendant; second, in failing to decide that the acknowledgment of the plaintiffs in this case had no other effect than the bearing of the surname of their father and the right to receive support; third, in ordering defendant to support the minor Héctor Luis, who, at the time of filing the amended complaint, was over 17 years of age; fourth, in fixing a monthly allowance of $94; and, fifth, in ordering the defendant to pay attorney’s fees and fixing the amount in $350.

The first assignment is grounded on the fact that since plaintiff Juan Rosario, at the time of filing the amended complaint on February 6,1946, had reached the age of majority, he could not be represented in the action by his mother Maria Rosario. This question was not raised in the lower court, but, in any event, the error assigned lacks merit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.